5 Best Breakfast Sandwich Makers 2023: Review & Buying Guide

If you are in the market to buy the best breakfast sandwich makers, you have made the right choice. A sandwich is the highly preferred breakfast meal for most parents, students, and service holders who are in a hurry. So you can get a ready-made sandwich on the way to your destination. But if you have the best sandwich maker in your home, you can easily prepare a hot and delicious sandwich. Also, having a good sandwich maker in your kitchen lets you tweak the ingredients, which can be healthy and fresh.

When you buy a new sandwich maker, you can explore beyond the egg and cheese sandwich. You can also add your favourite ingredients such as tomatoes, mushrooms, ham, sausage, bacon, and more. If eating a sandwich is your daily morning habit, making them at home is the best decision using your sandwich maker. It is healthy and saves you money.

Most people have eggs, bacon, and bread as the primary and straightforward breakfast meal. However, preparing them discretely requires lots of time and utensils. Also, who would want to clean the greasy fry pans in the morning? Well, in this situation, the sandwich maker comes as a Savior to you. Using the best sandwich maker, you can cook slices of bread, eggs, and meat along with cheese simultaneously within 5 minutes.

The Best Breakfast Sandwich Makers in 2023

The best breakfast sandwich maker saves you valuable time for preparing the morning meal. It makes not only a breakfast sandwich but also various snacks and dinner meals. And a great breakfast sandwich maker is the backbone of making a delicious sandwich. So in this post, we have analyzed every aspect of the top breakfast sandwich makers considering many critical factors. And after scrutinizing all pros and cons, we have come up with the best 5 breakfast sandwich makers. Using our sandwich makers’ research, you will get all the necessary facts to choose the best breakfast sandwich maker for your kitchen.

1. Hamilton Beach Breakfast Sandwich Maker, Black (25477)

Hamilton Beach Breakfast Sandwich Maker represents two things: the brand and the quality. This company is in the kitchen manufacturing business for decades. So you can undoubtedly trust the company as well as the product quality. Using this premium sandwich maker, you can cook hot and delicious sandwiches for breakfast, lunch, and dinner within 5 minutes. If you are in a hurry and have no time to spare, you can use this sandwich maker for cooking a quick and healthy meal on the go.

We like the custom sandwich-making feature. To make you surprised, this kitchen appliance comes with a custom sandwich cooking function. If you are a Keto and Paleo diet follower, you can discard the bread and make a completely custom sandwich with your choice like bread, cheese, eggs, meats, mushrooms, and more.

With Hamilton Beach Breakfast Sandwich Maker, you can cook a hot and hearty sandwich in just 4 steps. Firstly, add your favorite bread and precooked meat at the bottom of the cooking plate. Put cheese on top of it if you like. Secondly, add the egg to the egg plate. Thirdly, put the second bread at the top of the egg and close the lid. Fourthly, you can slide the egg plate out to the maker after cooking. It comes with a durable and nonstick coating surface that makes this sandwich maker dishwasher safe.

This kitchenware can cook one sandwich at a time. To be creative, the manufacturer has added more than 25 sandwich making recipes on their website.

  • The setup is cool.
  • You can control the cooking
  • All internal parts can be cleaned well in the sink.
  • The price tag is good
  • You can cook open-faced sandwiches.
  • The inner components are removable and dishwasher safe.
  • The cleaning is hassle-free.
  • Requires lots of power to heat up and cook

2. Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker with Timer, Silver (25490A)

“Two is better than one” – if you need to cook two sandwiches at the same time, Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker with Time can be your first choice. As the name suggests, it is equipped with extra parts that let you make two sandwiches. It comes with an audible countdown timer that lets you know when the sandwich is cooked thoroughly.

Like Hamilton Beach Breakfast Sandwich Maker, it uses the 4-steps method to cook delicious sandwich using your favourite and custom ingredients.

Making breakfast is easy if you use the Hamilton Beach Dual, sandwich maker. You have to plug in the machine first and preheat it. When the sandwich maker is preheated, you can put bread, precooked meat, or cheese at the bottom section. Now, lower the egg ring and crack an egg on the plate. Then put bread at the top of the egg and close the lid. When the cooking is completed, the audible timer will start beeping, and you will get a hot and delicious sandwich.

After cooking, let the sandwich maker cool down a bit and then clean it. You can wash them in the dishwasher because all internal parts are dishwasher safe.

  • The dual function with an audible timer saves time and energy.
  • It is perfect for a family with at least two members.
  • The green light indicates when the machine reaches the cooking temperature.
  • All internal parts are removable and dishwasher safe.
  • The audible countdown timer prevents overcooking.
  • The egg can soak into the bread with a hefty topping

3. Hamilton Beach Electric Panini Press Grill with Locking Lid, Opens 180 Degrees for any Sandwich Thickness (25460A) Nonstick 8″ X 10″ Grids Chrome Finish, Medium

Do you love Italian Panini? Well, let me introduce you to great kitchenware that can cook hot and delicious Panini. This cookware is known as Hamilton Beach Electric Panini Press Sandwich Maker. It has a café style lid that evenly presses all sandwiches no matter how to think the sandwich is.

With your favourite fresh ingredients, you can make Rueben sandwiches. Though this kitchenware looks big, the user manual is simple and easy-to-use. You will find two indicators: power and preheating buttons. The preheating light informs you that it is ready to cook when it turns green. For the perfect cooking, preheat the sandwich maker for 6 minutes, and the built-in ready light turns green when the press is ready. Because of the large surface, you can cook 2-3 sandwiches simultaneously.

Hamilton Beach Electric Panini Press Grill cooks savory sandwiches and quesadillas and warms pizza and open-face sandwiches. Do you worry whether the sandwich comes brown or burnt? Well, if you use this appliance, you do not have to flip over the sandwich. This simple kitchenware uses nonstick top and bottom Panini press grids that help the sandwich heat and make it brown. So you will get a warm and crisp sandwich.

  • The café-style floating lid presses any size sandwich evenly.
  • It uses nonstick coating for the top and bottom surfaces.
  • You can open it up to 180 degrees for any thick sandwich.
  • It is an Easy-to-use.
  • Stylish design and easily fits in your kitchen cabinet.
  • Not dishwasher safe.

It uses non-removable container plates that make it harder to clean.

4. Proctor Silex Sandwich Toaster, Omelet And Turnover Maker, White (25408Y)

If you are looking for a simple, compact, and small sandwich maker within your budget, then you can buy Proctor Silex Sandwich Toaster. This is the best kitchenware to replace your old frying pan. Proctor Silex Sandwich Maker is your perfect choice to cook a sandwich using a few fresh ingredients. Because of the small space, you cannot be so creative and add minimal ingredients between bread pieces. Using this sandwich maker, you can make other meals such as omelets, French toast, and desserts.

Because of its compact design and storage, you can quickly put it on the cabinet. It will not take much space. Similar to Hamilton sandwich makers, it has two indicators: power on and preheat lights. The preheat light signals you the time to put the bread in it. The 77 square inches surface is a perfect fit for slices of bread. The cooking manual is straightforward. Turn on the power, preheat this appliance, prepare the sandwich with your favorite ingredients, and put it inside. Now lock the lid and wait. Within 2-4 minutes, you will get a hot and delicious sandwich. However, you have to cut bread in a triangular shape.

Cleaning instruction is straightforward. After making a sandwich, cool it down for some time. Then wipe the plates clean with damp cloths.

  • Cheap and within budget
  • Easy to use
  • Preheat quickly
  • Sealed the edges neatly
  • Simple cleaning
  • Perfect for sliced and regular-sized bread
  • Fit triangular-shaped small sized bread
  • Need to cut the bread into half
  • No grill pattern

5. Cuisinart WM-SW2N Dual-Sandwich Nonstick Electric Grill

With this single sandwich maker, you can cook not only sandwiches but also omelets and French toast. This kitchenware is perfect for cooking simple two sandwiches. Also, you can use it for making a sandwich as well as grilling cookware.

Cuisinart Dual Sandwich Maker has a simple cooking manual. Preheat this appliance first, and prepare the sandwich ingredients in the meantime. After preparing the whole sandwich, put it on the grill surface. Now close the lid gently, and the cooking will begin. This machine comes with two light indicators: red and green. The green light shows the preheating status, and the red light hint when the sandwich is cooked perfectly. These lights prevent under-cooking and overcooking.

Like other sandwich makers we have discussed above, it uses nonstick plates at the top and bottom sections. So you will not find grease and rust in the internal parts that make it easy to clean the surface. When you complete cooking, you can wipe the internal components and the outer side using a damp cloth. But you must cool it down before start cleaning.

The sealed locking mechanism is another useful function of the Cuisinart Dual-Sandwich Nonstick Electric sandwich maker. The perfect lid-locking method assures that all edges are sealed correctly to keep the ingredients stuffed inaccurately. The ultimate compact and small design make it easy to store anywhere, even in the kitchen cabinets.

  • Robust design
  • Grill as well as cook
  • Light-weighted
  • Simple to clean
  • Small surface

How to Choose the Best Breakfast Sandwich Makers (Buying Guide)

In this buying guide analysis, we will discuss what to look for and what features you should consider when choosing the best breakfast sandwich maker among the numerous products.

Types of Sandwich Makers

When you browse online to buy a new breakfast sandwich maker, you may probably find many different sandwich makers available. Each one is different in terms of shapes, functions, and layers. So it’s up to you which type of sandwich maker you prefer.

The layered sandwich maker lets you pile up the ingredients and cook simultaneously. It also cooks faster and limits the mess for simple cleanup. However, the size of the layered sandwich makers is big and takes more space on your counter. On the other hand, egg-based sandwich makers have a compact design that cooks the egg in a shape that perfectly fits bread, bun, or English muffin.

One vs. Multiple Cook Setting

Typically, the most essential and budget breakfast sandwich makers have one or two cooking settings: preheating and complete cooking. You have a single setting for cooking, and you cannot control or adjust how brown or crisp your sandwich will get. On the other hand, many expensive and hi-tech breakfast sandwich makers have more cooking settings; you can control the temperature and even adjust the cooking method while using multiple ingredients. Also, different cooking settings provide various tastes and flavors that allow you to change the cooking methods.

One or Two Sandwiches

How many sandwiches your breakfast sandwich maker can cook will depend on price, size, and function. We have found that half of the sandwich makers can cook a single sandwich at a time; the other half can cook two sandwiches. The single sandwich maker can cost you less than the double sandwich maker. Also, the single sandwich makers have a compact design and will take less space. So which sandwich maker you should buy depends on how many sandwiches you prefer to cook. Generally, if you want to buy a breakfast sandwich maker for your family, then the double sandwich maker will be best.

Lid Lock

A cover lock or lid lock is an essential part of every sandwich maker because the lid lock joints the bottom part with the top part of your sandwich maker. This lid lock lets you cook the sandwich evenly. Also, it seals the sandwich in-between the two parts. You will find two types of locks: buckle clip and hinged lock. The sandwich makers are small, and light-weighted kitchen appliances and the prices are cheap. So you must understand that each part is not heavy. That’s why we suggest handling the lock carefully and put the lid lock with gentle pressure. However, to get the best sandwich maker, check the lid lock first. The weak or fragile lock will break easily.

Safety First Function

When you decide to buy a good sandwich maker, it is worth to check the safety measures the appliance can offer. Many sandwich makers use fully encircled griddle or cook plates. That feature prevents you from accidentally burning your hands. Also, these kitchenware machines come with cool-touch handles that will prevent burns when you open or close this appliance. Besides, many sandwich makers provide the auto shut-down function that automatically turns off the sandwich maker when the sandwich is cooked correctly. This auto-shutdown feature prevents accidental fire.

Nonstick Surface Plates

Most of the sandwich makers use nonstick griddle plates. So you can remove the cooked sandwich from this kitchenware easily. Also, you can clean the plates quickly if the leftover drips out. So before choosing the best breakfast sandwich maker for your budget, you should check whether this appliance has fully built-in plates or not.

Indicator buttons

You should buy the perfect sandwich maker with at least one indicator light: the button that shows when the sandwich is cooked correctly. We have described above all sandwich makers have at least a green light indicator that alerts you when this kitchenware finishes the cooking. The expensive or high-end sandwich makers have three light indicators: red, green, and yellow that let you cook the sandwich within your preferred temperature.

Plastic vs. Metal Handle

The sandwich makers use two types of handles: plastic and steel. The plastic handle breaks easily if you buy this kitchenware at a cheap rate. Also, the plastic handle cannot absorb much heat and becomes fragile. But the steel handle is more robust than the plastic handle. Because of the metal component, it can absorb more heat. And, of course, the metal handle lasts longer. So we suggest buying a good sandwich maker with a steel handle.

You Might Also Like: Best 5 Kitchen Tools Must Need In Your Kitchen

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How to use a breakfast sandwich maker?

The cooking process is quick and straightforward. First, plug in the sandwich maker and preheat for a few seconds. Most sandwich makers come with a preheat indicator; that means it will signal you when the machine is preheated. While preheating the device, you can prepare your favourite ingredients; fresh eggs, precooked meat, and a slice of cheese are the common ones. Also, do not forget the bread. When the sandwich maker is preheated, put the bread, meat, or cheese at the bottom plate, then crack the egg on the upper plate and put bread on the top. Then cover the lid lock. That’s it. When the sandwich is ready, the green light will indicate you.

2. How to clean the sandwich maker?

As the sandwich maker is small and compact kitchenware, it is easy to clean. However, before cleaning the machine, unplug it and cool it down completely. Now soak a cloth and wipe the top and bottom plates using the damp cloth. Also, wipe the outside surface using the same wet cloth. After wiping, dry the machine completely.

3. Can you cook or warm anything other than a sandwich?

Of course, but not all models offer multi-function features. The high-end and expensive sandwich makers allow cooking sandwich and other meals and snacks such as pancakes, burgers, grilled cheese sandwiches, and Panini.

4. How to prevent the sandwich maker from sticking?

Maximum sandwich makers come with nonstick coated plates. So the food will not stick to the plates. However, if the plates are not nonstick coated, brush the top and bottom plates with cooking oil before making a sandwich. Also, you can spread butter on the outside of the bread.

Also Check: The Best Air Fryer Reviews

Our Verdict

We have analyzed and listed the reviews of the 5 best breakfast sandwich makers among the many sandwich makers. We have reviewed each sandwich maker and discussed all aspects, pros, and cons of these sandwich makers. Using our info and features, you can now decide which sandwich maker will be best for you.

Leave a Comment